CD Baby - news, ideas, opinions, tips, announcements, and more.
find
news index | search | archive | ADD news! | links | cdbaby.com | cdbaby.net
PICK A SUBJECT...

CD Baby news


Digital Distribution


Website Changes


News from Outside


Marketing Ideas


Musician Announcement


Need your feedback!


Opportunities


Derek's Report



Older Stories
Tuesday
  • Will Do Free Soundtracks! looking for experience! (0)

  • MUSIC-WANTED.COM is now FREE - forever! (5)

  • The First Solo Album For King David (0)

  • CD Baby Wants Your Story - Part 2 (0)

  • Geoff Lapp Trio in Ourstage Top Ten for over 4 months (0)

  • Geoff Lapp Trio gets aired on Fame Games (0)

  • Geoff Lapp Trio gets aired on Game Games (0)

  • ‘Spoken Wor(l)d’: In Celebration of Human Speech (0)

  • Top 10 Indie Music Marketing Tools (1)

  • BULK Email Solution (1)

  • Anyone hear about SongVault? (1)

  • Management.... (0)


  • CD Baby Polls
    What's your FAVORITE thing about CD Baby?
    Getting paid every week
    Cute emails
    Selling to foreign strangers
    Friendly service
    Knowing the customers' info
    something else entirely
    [ results | polls ]

    3147 checks for $69,050.13 last week!
    posted by Derek Sivers on Thursday January 03 2002 @ 05:34PM PST
    Derek's Report Wow... last week, on December 31, I wrote 3147 checks to musicians - for a total of $69,050.13 - just for last week alone!

    That's puts us over the $1 million mark: over $1 million paid to musicians since I started this little "hobby"

    (...and boy is my signature hand tired!)

    :-)

    Gotta watch out when you start a little hobby "on the side." Never know when it's gonna totally take off.

    For those who don't know, just 2-3 years ago CD Baby was something I ran out of my living room, just selling my own CD, and a few friends' CDs. It was meant to be a hobby since I made my living by touring.

    But word-of-mouth turned it into this THING... which had customers... and MORE customers... buying lots and LOTS of CDs!

    All without trying.

    I think there's some kind of Taoist lesson in here.




    by Mike on Thursday January 03 2002 @ 08:07PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    $43 of that is mine! Thanks Derek!

    Slow Children at Play - http://www.SCAPmusic.com
    "We're not as bad as we sound"

    by hello on Friday January 04 2002 @ 10:52AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Self-congratulations, not surprizing.

    An average of $21 an artist, with over half the
    artists getting nothing at all.

    It's not weird its just a numbers game. If you
    have 50 artists, you'd have paid probably
    $400. If you have 8000 or 9000 you pay
    $69,000. It's not weird, it's just a numbers
    game. Simple math. Double your titles next
    year and you'll be cutting checks for $138,000
    a week. Still probably an average of $21 ann
    artist, and still over half the artists not getting
    paid.

    Double, triple or quadruple the average per
    artist - then you'll be doing something 'weird'.

    by andrew / diffusion records on Monday January 07 2002 @ 08:58AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    CD Baby is a great retailer, which is more artist-friendly than any other outlet I've ever come across.

    I challenge anyone to find another place out there that will take your $14 CD, hold on to as many copies as your want them to, host a website for it, put them in style-organized galleries, sell them via a variety of shipping methods, and then give you $10 back per disc.

    As far as the "number" game goes, please remember that it's really just a fulfillment outlet. You still have to do the same awful drudge work as before: promotion, marketing, and publicity. Almost all of our CDBaby sales come through people referred by external sources (#1 word of mouth, #2 MP3.COM, #3 listening to music samples on the website)

    The $21/artist average comes from Derek's generosity at including everyone who wants to be a part of the store, not from his "failing to sell your CD", because in the end that's really your job.

    Cheers,
    Andrew

    Diffusion Records
    http://www.diffusionrecords.com

    by David @ Kathode Ray Music on Monday January 07 2002 @ 02:54PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I started an online CD store in 1996, two years
    before CD Baby. Derek makes it look easy,
    but don't be fooled. This is hard work.


    by James Owen on Friday January 04 2002 @ 11:15AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Thanks Derek: I've sold a few through CDbaby and am very pleased to have a cool site to have people sample my CD before purchasing.
    Keep up the good work because it's a great idea.

    James Owen

    by mat on Tuesday January 08 2002 @ 08:40AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    it is very hard to sell anything on-line. its all about gaining the users trust and that is something Cdbaby has managed to do. Also how can you expect to sell your music if you don't put the effort in. The artists on my site (www.glasswerk.co.uk hrumph) that get the most number of listens and traffic are those that work on promoting themselves.

    by Pops Walker on Tuesday January 08 2002 @ 04:42PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Derek mentions that this was a hobby...that he wasn't even trying...that the CD Baby success story is a surprise to him...that it might even be a Taoist lesson.

    Here's my take. Much like Derek, I haven't really tried to make a success of my music. It's something I do as a labor of love. It isn't about the money. Hell, I don't really promote myself. I'd rather go fishing.

    But know this. Because of Derek's efforts, his no-frills, but honest business approach, not to mention his stewardship of independent artists' efforts, my CD is now being heard in Belgium, Switzerland, England, Japan, Canada, and God knows where else throughout the US.

    Am I getting rich off of his efforts? Hell no. But that's not his responsibility. What Derek offers is a chance for us to put our music out there. If it's good, we'll know. People will contact us. Listeners will write us. The audience will show itself - but only if we, as musicians have earned it. Earning it, is our role - not Derek's.

    Bottom line: Derek, and the other folks at CD Baby give us a venue. They give the independent musicians a chance to speak. And they do it with care, sincerity, honesty, and with a bit of flair and humor. It's up to us, the Indies, to take advantage of that chance.

    So, to recap: I'm not getting rich from CD Baby. But I'm not trying to do so. All I asked of them was to offer my music via the "net". They've done that and more. I can't even imagine what will happen when I really try to promote myself.

    And a final note to all the staff at CD Baby: I love you guys. Thanks. Pops Walker.

    by Bridget St John on Wednesday January 09 2002 @ 11:07AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I have to say, I am so happy with CD Baby! Derek kept his word that I would get my very own page, sound bites, and my money! I need that alternate source for sound bites and exposure. Because of that, I actually sold to someone who was just browsing and liked what they heard! Thank you and Congratulations Derek and every at Baby headquarters!

    by hello on Wednesday January 09 2002 @ 12:34PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I should host Politically Incorrect instead of
    Maher.

    Perspective, boys and girls, perspective. Just
    presenting perspective as to why it's not
    'weird' - don't take it as if I was slandering your
    mother, Rudi Juliani, or the Pope.

    "I challenge anyone to find another place out
    there that will take your $14 CD, hold on to as
    many copies as your want them to, host a
    website for it, put them in style-organized
    galleries, sell them via a variety of shipping
    methods, and then give you $10 back per disc.
    "
    Here's a couple, found in about 2 minutes on
    Google:

    http://www.planetcd.com
    http://www.evor.com
    http://www.indierec.com
    http://www.indie-cds.com
    http://www.guitar9.com
    http://www.cddebut.com
    http://www.joesgrille.com

    Come up with a harder challenge.

    (Actually a quick way to find them is to search
    for Tim Sweeny, the guy had the presence of
    mind to send his columns to every one of
    them.)

    "I started an online CD store in 1996, two
    years before CD Baby. Derek makes it look
    easy, but don't be fooled. This is hard work."

    Anybody that knows you David knows that the
    reason your store didn't suceed was that you
    had way too many irons in the fire, and didn't
    watch the 'store'.

    The 'perspective' here is that if you believe the
    hype on this site - that this is the only game in
    town (there is no one that can prove or
    disprove that claim), Sweeny himself is
    spreading that nonsense, and the truth is that
    indies are selling CDs all over the net. Since
    they have to 'do the work', why shouldn't they?

    by David @ Kathode Ray Music on Monday January 14 2002 @ 08:52PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Hello sez: Anybody that knows you David
    knows that the reason your store didn't
    suceed was that you had way too many irons
    in the fire, and didn't watch the 'store'.


    Good comment.

    There were a number of reasons that my store
    failed, but I'd say that this was definitely one of
    them. My heart wasn't in it, the time wasn't
    right, etc.

    The opposite is true for CD Baby. The fact that
    Derek is concentrating on CD Baby is the
    main reason why it has been a success.

    Somebody mentioned something about Derek
    starting CD Baby in order to be able get back
    to doing music. I don't think that that is true
    and I'd argue that Derek is as much into
    marketing, programming, and everything else
    involved with running CD Baby as he is into
    music.

    I remember talking to Derek in 1998 right after
    he started CD Baby. I was shocked when he
    told me that his shopping cart for the store
    was about $1500.

    The shopping cart to CD Baby is important,
    but my reason for mentioning it is just an
    example to show that when Derek Sivers does
    something, he does it right. He could
    do a lot less than he does, such as getting a
    free shopping cart, and I'm sure he could
    make a lot more money than he does by
    cutting costs, but he's chosen to do things in a
    solid manner rather than take shortcuts, patch
    holes, etc.


    by Malcolm Humes on Wednesday January 09 2002 @ 09:01PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Wow! I remember visiting Derek around April 1998 when CD Baby *was* just a baby in his living room, probably not shipping more than a handful of CDs a month.

    "Numbers game" or not, I'm quite impressed seeing him take it from a idea to a reality and using a vision that he has stuck with that seems to have carried through all the economic crises faced by Net based business models. I've worked at an Internet company that burned $1 million a month of venture capital with virtually no product and no revenue.

    When I saw a quote in WIRED's site mentioning recent sales figures I figured Derek had sold off the business. Doesn't look like it, though I guess he moved it to Portland? (I love the bridges there and Powells.com's city block of used books.)

    There may be other sites trying to do the same thing, but I believe this one is one of the most sincere and artist oriented, and also founded and run by a musician!

    And he offeres a lot of thoughts and resources on marketing. I'm sure they're linked in somewhere here but check out:

    http://www.marketingyourmusic.com and
    http://www.musicthoughts.com

    or a nice interview I found where he questions the industry's idea that giving away MP3's hurts CD sales:

    http://www.indiejournal.com/indiejournal/interviews/dereksivers.htm

    All I can say is, count me in the fan club for Derek as not only a great musician but an admirable marketing wiz. I hope you're still recording music too!

    It's great to see CD Baby still alive and kicking.

    - Malcolm

    by Christopher Wilson on Wednesday January 09 2002 @ 09:27PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Hats off to Derek and all the staff at CD Baby for providing us independent artists a great opportunity for additional exposure (aside from our hometown ventures). You guys rawk...:<)

    by hello on Thursday January 10 2002 @ 05:57AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "Numbers gameor not, I'm quite impressed
    seeing him take it from a idea to a reality and
    using a vision that he has stuck with that
    seems to have carried through all the
    economic crises faced by Net based
    business models. "

    Heck, I'm impressed too, you'd have to be nuts
    not to be, but are these numbers here to
    impress?

    by Linda Draper on Thursday January 10 2002 @ 08:27AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "Heck, I'm impressed too, you'd have to be nuts not to be, but are these numbers here to impress?"

    "Perspective, boys and girls, perspective."

    Perspective - (2)a mental view of the relationship of aspects of a subject to each other and to a whole. (3)An idea of the relative importance of things.

    Hello, you are presenting YOUR perspective, not perspective in its entirety. That's impossible for any single person to do, no matter how right they THINK they are...be it your mother, the Pope, Rudi Juliani, or Rudy Guiliani. But now, you've not only shared YOUR perspective, you've also answered your own question. Congratulations.


    by Willie T on Thursday January 10 2002 @ 09:17AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I think Derek has done a superb job at making our music available to the world. Are there other sites that do this? Sure there are, but this is by far the most artist friendly outfit that I've come across yet. Derek has done everything he has offered to do for new CD Baby artists (for a reasonable fee), and surprisingly much more. He is always coming up with new tips and clever marketing ideas that can benefit us all if we take advantage of them. The rest of the staff is very responsive as well, and friendly as can be.

    Promoting CD sales is the artist's business primarily. CD Baby has given us some great tools.
    The rest is up to us. I've been making only a very modest effort to promote my music, I admit. (a full-time job and parenting two small kids does take a toll on my musical pursuits). Still, Willie T & Doctor X have sold more CDs through CD Baby than we have ever sold through record stores or through any other website (and to some pretty far-flung places that were previously beyond our reach). With a little more effort on my part, I hope to increase those sales substantially in 2002. Thanks, Derek, for all you do for us!

    by hello on Thursday January 10 2002 @ 10:48AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "Hello, you are presenting YOUR perspective,
    not perspective in its entirety."

    Yes, I see you have a firm grasp on the
    obvious.

    Who's perspective did you think I was
    presenting?

    by c. basinet on Friday January 11 2002 @ 08:00PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Thank you, Derek for taking your "hobby" of making my "hobby", a successful enterprise.

    All the continued best in '02~
    Cynthia

    by Dan E on Saturday January 12 2002 @ 06:11AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Wheeeew....Ouch.....Hey!
    Quit it! *Ouch* Quit it!

    Okay...now that's out of the way.

    Congrats Derek!
    Ya Stood the Storm!

    I'd like to add my "addaboyz"
    to Derek & cdbaby now.

    Hard Party was considering
    not sending a new shipment
    of our last cd, HOWEVER our Management
    said "NO" you'll send more and the
    New release as well.
    I have to ablige or loose the contract.

    The main reasons for me not wanting to
    send more is, I don't trust the net.
    And we don't really do well at cd sales
    on the internet anywhoz. "HOWEVER"
    The recent exposer we've received
    was through "Derek's Work" & this site cdbaby.
    It Was "Not" Hard Party's promoting,
    we've been very Slack about
    promoting the cd sale here to say the least.

    TMALSS
    Hard Party was contacted through
    Cdbaby's artists email for a feature
    article at Hardline Magazine in Munich Germany.

    It May not be a deal to most
    but to HP management and the band
    we think it's pretty kool!

    I even saw a band Hurricane featured
    there (Saw Them in ATL.Ga. @ Fox Theater)
    with Stryper in the 80's.
    And they're also doing a piece on
    one of my favorite Europian
    bands from the 70's "MAGNUM"
    What a hoot! Well I think so.

    ATFAT
    Thanks Derek & Cdbaby Staff.
    We didn't sell a cd but....
    We couldn't have paid for
    the exposer we've received.

    PS
    We gotz the Check....Thank You!

    Dan E Lee
    Hard Party



    by hello on Saturday January 12 2002 @ 09:08AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    OK, then let's cut to the chase.

    You can subtitle this thread, "Thanks man for
    helping me sell a couple of CDs, with or
    without my own participation or interest, but
    what I really shoudl have done was stop
    messing about in music, and started a
    business catering to others who'd like to sell a
    couple CDs a month because I could make
    enough money to hire everyone to do the grunt
    work while I go back to making music, only
    this time, my bills are paid."

    by Sam on Sunday January 13 2002 @ 02:32AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Oh my GOD will you get a LIFE, "Hello"? Derek and
    CDBaby are the friendliest, most approachable
    team. They're always willing to offer tips,
    advice, and just go the extra mile that a lot of
    those other companies don't. I mean, hell, Derek
    even takes the time out to personally respond to
    emails himself. At most other companies you get
    some assistant who doesn't know his ass from his
    elbow.

    I think your musical frustration with the fact
    that you haven't "hit the bigtime" as it sounds
    was your (unachieved) goal has clouded your
    intellect. As many people have wisely stated
    previously, it is not Derek's nor CDBaby's
    responsability to promote or sell our CDs, our
    success relies SOLELY on us.

    Maybe it's time you realize that the reason you
    are a frustrated musician is that you have been
    living under the notion that everyone else is
    supposed to do the work FOR you...are you a
    spoiled momma's boy whose daddy owns a big company
    that you'll inherit one day?

    Work harder to achieve musical success....it's
    YOUR responsability. And don't forget to get a
    life while you're out...

    by andrew / diffusion records on Sunday January 13 2002 @ 09:43PM PST [ reply | parent ]

    >You can subtitle this thread, "Thanks man for
    >helping me sell a couple of CDs, with or

    A couple? To date, we've almost sold two hundred through CDBaby.

    - Andrew

    p.s. I've noticed that your posts in other threads seem to be as disparaging and spiteful as in this one. Maybe you should channel all of that negative energy and start your own online CD store, hey maybe you can call it "AngryBaby"

    Diffusion Records
    http://www.diffusionrecords.com



    by hello on Monday January 14 2002 @ 11:29AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "A couple? To date, we've almost sold two
    hundred through CDBaby."

    Hey dude, pay attention, I am talking per
    month, with a few CDs selling 3-5 copies a
    month each, eventually you hit 200, just as if
    you will eventually hit age 21.

    "Maybe it's time you realize that the reason you
    are a frustrated musician."

    I can't play a note of music, I am actually a fan
    of the site and sites like it. I like to offer
    alternative views that put numbers and other
    'statistics' into perspective. Yes (again) my
    perspective (who else's?).

    If I have a major frustration with the site it's as
    a customer, the limited or absent disclosure
    about what you are getting for your $10, $11,
    $12 or $15 is very frustrating. I can't stand
    CD-R or computer burned CDs with their
    cheapola graphics. There are tons of very fine
    CDs with professional packaging on the site,
    but do you think you can tell the difference by
    visiting the cookie cutter pages here?
    Nooooo.... And, I know, as a
    know-it-all-musician who probably doesn't buy
    CDs you probably would like to point out about
    the 14-day return policy, but I have to eat the
    frigging shipping every time I get a damn
    CD-R.

    "I've noticed that your posts in other threads
    seem to be as disparaging and spiteful as in
    this one."

    They are not spiteful, they offer another
    viewpoint. If you think anyone who disagrees
    with your view is spiteful - hang on for a crappy
    life - it's coming your way.


    by Derek Sivers on Tuesday January 15 2002 @ 11:25PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "hello" - which CD-Rs have you gotten so upset about? I'm asking this sincerely. I've never heard of a problem with them before. Please let me know.

    by hello on Wednesday January 16 2002 @ 12:36PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I don't like any of them Derek, they aren't worth
    a crap to me. If I could see on the page
    whether the CD was a real, manufactured CD
    from Discmakers, Oasis or better, or one of
    those cheap CD-R or DAM CDs I would never
    buy a CD-R or DAM CD, there's just too many
    quality CDs that were properly manufactered
    that I could get - the CD-R's remind me of
    once-offs and demo-ware (to steal a computer
    term). The problem with the site is ONE JUST
    DOESN't KNOW until it arrives in the mail - too
    late. That is just not customer friendly.

    by hello on Wednesday January 16 2002 @ 12:40PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I forgot to mention one thing too. This is of
    lessor importance but means something. If
    the artist is willing to stand behind and raise
    the money for, then publicize, promote and
    work behind a CD they manufactured 300, 500
    or 1000 copies for, then that means
    something, it's another sign of commitment to
    their art, and I for one would rather support a
    committed artist than one whose just 'testing' -
    I can't support them all, I just would like to
    know what I'm getting and what kind of
    recording artist I am supporting....

    by goodbye on Monday January 14 2002 @ 01:17PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I like doughnuts.
    :)

    by hello on Monday January 14 2002 @ 01:54PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    That reminds me of a tune, You Say Yes, I Say
    No, You Say Stop, I Say Go Go Go

    Uh oh, some copyright has just been violated I
    feel....

    by goodbye's answering machine on Monday January 14 2002 @ 02:41PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "You say why,
    and I say I don't know...
    OH NO!"
    -Beatles

    Goodbye can't talk right now. He's busy eating doughnuts. At the beep, please leave a message. beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeep!




    by patrick on Tuesday January 15 2002 @ 09:29PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Galaris is getting ready for a new look. We cater to Independent musicians. Sell your cd, read the classified adds, or just come check it out.

    http://www.galaris.com/independent

    by mat on Thursday January 17 2002 @ 06:14AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    wats your problem with CD-Rs. They work just as well as properley manufactured ones and perhaps not all artists can rasie the money to make a thousand copies of their CD.

    by hello on Thursday January 17 2002 @ 06:26AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    CD-Rs are, to quote that line from "The
    Commitments", they're shite.

    They are not just as good as properly
    manufactured ones, don't kid yourself, anyway,
    if people want to waste their money buying
    them fine, what I'm saying is I don't want any of
    the buggers. I think the customer has the right
    to disclosure, to knowing exactly what they are
    getting for $10, $11,$15 whatever. A CD-R is
    worth about $2, but since none sell for that
    low, there is no way to know which are which.

    " perhaps not all artists can rasie the money to
    make a thousand copies of their CD. "

    What can I say, when you can, you should,
    CD-Rs are crap.

    by David @ Kathode Ray Music on Friday January 18 2002 @ 09:59PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I agree with this. I think Gajoob does a good
    job of it. How common are CD-Rs here
    though? I didn't know there were any.

    by hello on Saturday January 19 2002 @ 06:00AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    David, there are a good number of CD-Rs
    here. I've just gotten some - surprise! - and
    was pretty pissed - I want to know which
    artists have gone the extra mile to get proper
    duplication. They know here at the site, they
    just won't tell us. If you could pick up and look
    at the CD (like in a cool record store, which is
    mentioned on this site plenty of times as the
    offline analogy), you could avoid the buggers.
    Short of that, you need to be notified.

    by James Owen on Friday January 18 2002 @ 08:53AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Ok if it will make you happy, I had mine replicated through Oasis. It even has a barcode, and is shrinkwrapped. Good enough for you? Buy this one! Based on your comments, it's probably gonna be too mellow for you, but what the hell you wanted quality manufacturing and packaging!
    Dereck's idea has allowed all musicians to allow you to have access to their music. Thats big!
    If that's not good enough then start one yourself.
    Like the man said, it ain't easy. James Owen

    by hello on Friday January 18 2002 @ 09:27AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    James, it might help if you pay attention to the
    thread. We were talking about disclosure. In
    short, does or does not a customer have the
    right, pre-purchase, to know whether they are
    buying a manufactured CD (Oasis, Disc
    Makers or better) or a computer-burned,
    home-made, laser-printed-on-cheap paper,
    blue-backed CD-R? If I get a CD from Tower,
    Best Buy or CD Now, I don't have to know, they
    are all manufactured. Why is it a big secret on
    this site? Stick to the thread man.

    by Tsgili Waya on Monday January 21 2002 @ 01:15AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Hello, I understand what your saynig. You have the right to know, if you dislike CD-R's for one reason or another, then that is your problem.

    But not all CD-R's come with cheap graphics, I have seen some that look just as good as Glass-Mastered CD's

    Are those cheap graphics really all that bugs you? Or do you have a T-Rex Cd Player that won't play 'em?

    by hello on Monday January 21 2002 @ 06:29AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    "You have the right to know, if you dislike
    CD-R's for one reason or another, then that is
    your problem. "

    No, it is not my problem, it my concern and my
    beef -- it is this site's problem. Your smart
    ass response about the graphics and my CD
    player only confirms what I suspect: that a lot
    of musicians have trouble putting themselves
    in the position of the consumer - you'd prefer
    creating a lesser product (CD-R, hand-made
    graphics) for your own convenience, rather
    than provide a standard product that the
    consumer is knowledgable about and is
    comfortable with. How many indie CD-Rs
    have you purchased over the past year, Tsgili
    Waya? How many indie CDs total? How
    many non-indie CDs?

    For this site to go to the next level, someone
    has to start putting themselves in the shoes of
    the consumer, who, last time I checked (and
    with all due respect), pays ALL THE BILLS
    AROUND HERE. Just like every other
    business. But where a lot of business start to
    lose it is when they put other things first,
    ahead of the consumers concerns and
    issues.

    A musician-friendly site is wonderful, about
    time too, but....

    Any business that puts shareholders,
    employees, executives, owners, vendors (in
    this case, the artists), receivables,
    debtholders or any other party ahead of the
    customer is only one thing in the long run - out
    of business.

    I repeat my concern for clarity one more time:
    There are more than 15,000 SKUs on this
    site, only the people who run the site know
    which ones are CD-Rs and which ones aren't,
    which ones are CD-Rs being charged like a
    manufactured CD - All I'm saying - how's
    about sharing that with Joe Customer?

    by Ed Teja on Tuesday January 22 2002 @ 07:21AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I for one, was not aware that any customers made a disctinction between CDRs and mastered glass, except for, perhaps, calssical music. For my blues, you aren't gonna get high fidelity (cause it is just guitar, vocal and harp --narrow band of frequencies there) no matter what you do.

    CDRs let musicians do the equivalent of "print on demand" publishing, which I consider viable. I stand behind my work, but I haven't the space to inventory 1,000 CDs (the minimum it is practical to order manufactured). Print on demand books are not labeled as such, even on Amazon.com (go ahead, ask me how I know--I been at this a LONG time) although the physical quality is certainly different (not worse) than mass produced books.

    I disagree that a CDR is worth $2, as the physical medium, produced, printed on, wrapped and ready to go, costs me at least that much, and I think I deserve something for the music. The package is not the point anyway, unless you are just a pure consumer, acquiring for acquisition. It is a means to deliver music. And as I said, no one has gotten my CD has complained--well, at least not about it being a CDR.

    by hello on Tuesday January 22 2002 @ 09:32AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Sorry, I forgot one:

    "I stand behind my work"

    Then you would have no problem if a
    customer visiting your page on this site saw
    the phrase "This is a CD-R release"... It is
    what it is. Let the marketplace determine the
    value.

    by hello on Tuesday January 22 2002 @ 08:51AM PST [ reply | parent ]
    Man, resposes such as that from Ed Teja, I
    hope don't reflect the average musician on the
    site - you couldn't all be this arrogant - jeez
    louise!

    "I for one, was not aware that any customers
    made a disctinction between CDRs and
    mastered glass"

    Consider yourself aware now. The lack of a
    customer Forum on this site would make real
    feedback difficult.

    "CDRs let musicians do the equivalent of
    "print on demand" publishing, which I
    consider viable."

    You might consider it viable, I don't - I don't
    want 'em, don't need 'em, there are thousands
    and throusands of regular CDs on this site to
    pick from (at least a hundred times available
    cash to spend) so tell me which are which
    and let me (the customer) decide. When you
    are doing the buying, YOU decide.

    "but I haven't the space to inventory 1,000
    CDs"

    And I have to pay the price for that?!?

    "1,000 CDs (the minimum it is practical to
    order manufactured)"

    Now that's just bull chips. Go to Discmakers
    and they have nice 300 CD packages, two of
    my acquantences at work have had those
    made.

    "Print on demand books are not labeled as
    such, even on Amazon.com"

    If that were true I, and I got one, I'd return it and
    cease shopping there and go back to Borders,
    where I can see and touch what I'm paying for,
    and the coffee is better too.

    "I disagree that a CDR is worth $2, as the
    physical medium, produced, printed on,
    wrapped and ready to go, costs me at least
    that much, and I think I deserve something for
    the music."

    You can set the value at whatever you want
    provided you are paying for it. I set the value to
    me at less than $2, and even then I'd just give
    it a few listens, toss it and wait for the full
    length.

    "no one has gotten my CD has
    complained--well, at least not about it being a
    CDR"

    Just be honest about what it is upfront, and
    you won't get any complaints now or in the
    future.

    "The package is not the point anyway"

    I disagree, the artists who take the extra time
    to put together a quality product should get
    extra attention. Let's say out of 15,000 artists
    on this site that 12,000 have regular CDs and
    3,000 are pushing CD-Rs as CDs, I'd focus
    on the 12,000 with regular CDs, amd even
    then there's no way I could even begin to
    sample (much less buy) that much music -
    you fail to take into account the amount of
    product out there.



    by Mark Rich on Thursday January 24 2002 @ 01:27PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I for one appreciate hello's comments. It didn't occur to me to make it clear that our officially released CD is pressed, not burned. It does make sense.

    We'll be releasing some demos, which will probably be burned. It likewise makes sense to include the datum there. That would help us get across the point that these demos are for people wanting to hear the -songs-, not the people looking for a finished listening experience.

    Cheers,
    Mark
    Iguanodon Smile



    by hello on Thursday January 24 2002 @ 04:35PM PST [ reply | parent ]
    I don't know, but I would guess that other
    artists who've spent the extra money to get
    their CDs manufactured would want that fact
    known, if for no other reason than to have one
    more distinguishing factor for their product - a
    way to make your product stand out. I can
    speak better from the consumer standpoint --
    it's not right that I don't really know what I am
    getting.

    by